What is the Best Crib Mattress for a Baby or Toddler?

Sleep Metro is entirely supported by its readers. When you purchase any product through the branded referral links on my site, I receive a commission at no additional expense to you. In addition, as an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Need to know more? Read about my research and review process.

best crib mattress for baby

With so many options available, finding the best crib mattress for your baby can be overwhelming. You want a mattress that is durable, comfortable, and most importantly, safe for your baby. Babies spend a lot of time sleeping (even though it might not seem like it!) and they also grow rapidly. The mattress needs to properly fit the crib, be firm and provide support. You also may want to purchase a crib mattress that is a little bigger than your baby requires initially, so that you can get the most use out of it in the long-term.

Types of Crib Mattresses

There are two types of crib mattresses: foam and innerspring. They are both good options when they are made with high-quality products. Foam tends to be lighter: A feature you want to keep in mind as you will have to lift the mattress to change sheets and clean. Innerspring mattresses are popular because they are the most common choices. No matter which one you choose, ensure it is of a high quality. You don’t have to spend a lot of money for a good crib mattress, but too low of a price can be an indicator of poor quality. Cutting corners on the quality of your baby’s mattress is not an option.

Safety + Comfort + Quality

The three most important features for your baby’s crib mattress are safety, comfort and quality. Crib mattresses need to be firm as babies are continuously developing and their spines require support. It’s often easy for us to forget this fact, because our first instinct is to purchase a softer and more conforming mattress. When the mattress is too soft for your baby, it increases the risk for suffocation (SIDS: Sudden Infant Death Syndrome). In addition, you do not want one that will crack or flake as it poses a danger to your baby. It is important to remember that you want your baby and toddler to develop good sleeping habits now. Poor quality mattresses can lead to a variety of sleeping issues. The best crib mattress will provide firm, yet comfortable support with the highest quality products.

The following crib mattress reviews for five of the highest-rated ones on the market should make your decision easier. These mattresses all provide your baby with a safe and comfortable slumber. Each one offers some bonus features that may be important to you. So which one of these options is the best baby or toddler mattress for your little one? Read on to find out.

5 Best Baby Crib Mattress Reviews






Best Crib Mattress
Soybean oils. Combines comfort + technology. Good for newborns through to ages 4.
Extra firm
Best Crib Mattress
Brand best seller. Great value for money. 6-inch Memory Foam. Eco-friendly. Lightweight.
Dual-sided firmness levels
(1 side softer than the other)
best crib mattress
Imported. Hypo-allergenic. Durable. Amazon best seller. High-density fibre core for support.
best crib mattress
Good support. Lightweight. Good for infant to toddler years. Hypo-allergenic + plush comfort.
to Firm
best crib mattress
Anti-microbial protection. Easily cleaned. Economical. Hypo-allergenic. Comfort + safety.
Extra-firm on infant side. Firm on
toddler side.
best crib mattress

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress gives your baby a good night’s sleep by using soybean oils. The soybean oils -- sourced from American farmers -- reduce sagging, and increase durability. The mattress is firm, yet lightweight. The cover and binding are waterproof, stain-resistant, and easy to clean. This foam crib mattress is Greenguard Certified. It also comes with a lifetime warranty. The Sealy brand is award-winning, earning an America’s Best Brand for Baby Women’s Choice Award.

best crib mattress

The Colgate Eco Classica III is Colgate’s best-selling crib mattress. This mattress is eco-friendly and has a dual firmness design. Your baby sleeps on the firmer side, and when he or she grows into a toddler, you can flip the mattress over to the softer side. The firm memory foam is infused with plant oils for increased durability. The cover is PVC-free and waterproof. This crib mattress is Greenguard Gold Certified and made with CertiPUR-US certified safe foam. The mattress comes with an organic cotton cover. This crib mattress is 51.7 x 27.5 x 6 inches and weighs 9.4 pounds. It is made in the U.S.A.

best crib mattress

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress gives your baby firm support. It has a high-density thermo-bonded fiber core that is both lightweight and durable. The waterproof vinyl cover is easy to clean. This crib mattress is Greenguard Gold Certified, which means it meets standards for low chemical emissions. It is also free of phthalates and lead. The mattress measures 52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches so it fits standard cribs and toddler beds. It is hypo-allergenic. The Safety 1st crib mattress comes in 3 colors: white, light pink, and light blue.

best crib mattress

The Dream On Me Spring Crib & Toddler Mattress has 80 interwoven coils that offer a firm support on which your baby can sleep. The waterproof lock-stitched binding keeps mold, mildew, and odor out. The mattress is anti-bacterial and lightweight. A foam wrap provides extra comfort. It is easy to clean with soap and water. This mattress is 52 x 27 x 6 inches and weighs 10 pounds. It comes with a 10-year limited warranty.

best crib mattress

Considered as a more affordable option, The Little Dreamer mattress is designed with 5-inch thick high-quality medical grade foam that is CertiPUR-US certified. The brand, Moonlight Slumber, clearly has foresight and thinks beyond the infant stage. The mattress is usable on dual sides: an extra-firm high-density foam on the infant side as well as a firm high-density foam on the toddler side provides maximum comfort and use into your baby’s toddler years. With its square and cornered edges, side-stitched seams, simple shape and quality ticking, this mattress is also safe. It is free of any harsh chemicals, such as vinyl, polyethylene, PVC, phthalates, and lead. Its non-toxic, waterproof nylon cover is easily cleaned with a damp sponge. It measures 27.5 x 5 x 52 inches and weighs 10.3 pounds. Made in the U.S.A, this crib mattress is also Greenguard Gold Certified.

Closing Thoughts

When deciding on the best baby mattresses from which to choose, the theme that runs through this article is that support for a baby’s spine, which is vital for healthy growth, and safety from suffocation cannot be compromised on. Any one of the above-mentioned mattresses have the features that meet these criteria.